In this lecture we learnt about Theory X(authoritarian
management style) and Theory Y(participative
management style).
The Theory X managers think that their employees are not
inclined towards work. They have to be forced with the threat of punishment to
work.
On the other hand Theory Y managers think that employees
will put in their best to achieve the organizations goals.
Four cases arise in such a scenario:
1.
When the
worker is lazy and the manager assumes that the worker is lazy then
that manager may be a Theory X manager
2.
When the
worker is lazy and the manager assumes that the worker is not
lazy then that manager may be a Theory Y manager
3.
When the worker is not lazy and the Manager
assumes that the worker is lazy then the manager may be a Theory X manager
4.
When the
worker likes the work and the manager assumes that the worker is not
lazy then the manager may be a Theory Y manager
Let me give some examples from my work life experiences for
the same. The examples would be with reference to a colleague, who is a very
close friend of mine. Let us call him X. We both joined the organization at the
same time. We will see the cases mentioned above in the order in which they
occurred.
1.
Case 3: X was not lazy, but the project leader
would never be satisfied with his work. He would criticize him, rather I would
say embarrass him in front of everyone, and assume that X is just passing time.
2.
Case 1: As mentioned in case 3 X was not lazy,
but the treatment meted out to him made him lazy. Despite several one to one
conversations the same continued and X got demoralized and lost all dedication
towards work.
3.
Case 4: X has a new project team, and now he
directly reports to the project manager. He is keen to prove himself and his
manager motivates him all the way.
4.
Case 2: X to prepare for higher studies starts
putting in lesser time into work. But the manager still pushes him positively
to give it his best.